One law for the poor, another for the powerful
It is not disorder or damage to property that most endangers society, but the daily violence of hunger, corruption, and repression. It is the poor who are punished swiftly and harshly, while those truly responsible for the country’s decay are shielded from accountability.
September 26, 2025
NUPL
The National Union of Peoples’ Lawyers is a nationwide voluntary association of human rights lawyers in the Philippines, committed to the defense, protection, and promotion of human rights, especially of the poor and the oppressed.

The events of September 21 once more exposed the double standards that govern law enforcement in this country. More than 216 people were arrested, among them 91 minors. They were beaten, detained in squalid conditions. Some are accused of joining scuffles, but many were simply protesters and bystanders caught in the sweep. They now face charges for various tumults and disturbances and damage to property.

It is telling that the full force of the law is wielded by “Manila’s finest” in defense of private property, while violations of human rights, even by state agents, are whitewashed. In this society, a broken window is punished more swiftly than the beating of a child.

Such severity is reserved only for the poor. When the powerful are implicated in corruption and human rights abuse, the response could not be more different: investigations that drag on indefinitely, shifting of blame, or complete silence. Extrajudicial killings remain unpunished while political dynasties implicated in corruption return to office as if nothing happened.

This disparity has long been the rule. The same authorities that jail children for shouting slogans bends over backward to excuse those with money and influence. The same system that rushes to file charges against protesters has yet to hold accountable those responsible for plunder or the loss of billions in public funds.

It is not disorder or damage to property that most endangers society, but the daily violence of hunger, corruption, and repression. It is the poor who are punished swiftly and harshly, while those truly responsible for the country’s decay are shielded from accountability.

Law, if it is to mean anything, cannot be selective. Until these double standards end, its promise of justice will remain hollow.

Reference:

Atty. Josalee S. Deinla
NUPL Secretary General
+639174316396

Read more

Hands off NUPL Negros Chairperson Atty. Rey Gorgonio and PDG development workers! – NUPL

Hands off NUPL Negros Chairperson Atty. Rey Gorgonio and PDG development workers! – NUPL

These attacks against Atty. Gorgonio and his clients, whom the military has labeled as “high value individuals,” are part of the continuing weaponization of counterterrorism measures against development workers and human rights defenders. They create a chilling climate meant to intimidate and hinder human rights lawyers from independently performing their duties and providing legal services without fear.

On the Conviction of Frenchie Mae Cumpio and Marielle Domequil for Terrorism Financing

On the Conviction of Frenchie Mae Cumpio and Marielle Domequil for Terrorism Financing

For human rights defenders, humanitarian and religious workers, development NGO personnel, journalists, and community organizers, the unmistakable message is that legitimate social engagement and protected civic activity may be recast by the State as terrorism financing through broad and elastic standards untethered from real acts of terrorism. This shows how terror laws in the Philippines, by their nature and design, chill speech, deter association, and shrink civic space.

Share This